Analysis

How Vaughan Gething's historic victory turned into a short and turbulent stint as Wales first minister

Mr Gething's brief time as first minister was clouded by controversy, but his supporters believe his legacy will be as great as any.

Pic: Reuters
First Minister of Wales Vaughan Gething speaks during an interview with Reuters at the National Assembly for Wales, in Cardiff, Britain May 8, 2024. REUTERS/Francesca Jones
Image: Pic: Reuters
Why you can trust Leading wesley

Vaughan Gething's victory to become Wales's first minister was a historic moment, not just for the nation - but for Europe.

Upon his win, Mr Gething said it was an "honour" to be voted in as the first black leader of any European nation.

He said devolution was "in [his] blood" and finding "Welsh solutions to Welsh problems" was what he had "always known".

But the problems he faced during his short but turbulent time in office were many.

Allegations of a union nomination stitch-up emerged during the leadership campaign.

Critics also questioned Mr Gething's judgement and said he should not have accepted a £200k donation from a convicted environmental offender.

Mr Gething said the donation was within the rules and declared in line with party protocols. He refused calls for the money to be returned.

Pic: Joann Randles/Cover Images/AP
Image: Pic: Joann Randles/Cover Images/AP

His supporters argued Mr Gething had been "held to a higher standard" because he was black.

Welsh Labour's Black Asian and Minority Ethnic Committee said the treatment of him in the media had gone beyond what could be described as "fair scrutiny".

Familiar face

For many, Mr Gething had become one of the most familiar faces in Welsh politics.

He was the man tasked with running the Welsh NHS during the COVID pandemic and fronted frequent news conferences, providing updates on the latest rules and regulations in Wales.

Some bereaved families who lost loved ones to COVID have called for the government's decisions to be scrutinised by an independent inquiry specific to Wales - calls which have so far been refused.

He then sacked Hannah Blythyn, who was the deputy minister for social partnership, in May for allegedly leaking to the media - allegations she denies.

Minister for Health and Social Services Vaughan Gething by held his Cardiff South and Penarth seat with a majority of more than 10,000 votes
Image: Mr Gething was tasked with running the Welsh NHS during the pandemic

Mr Gething was seen by some as the continuity candidate to build on Mark Drakeford's legacy.

But some of his predecessor's policies have been U-turned, either partially or fully, during his brief spell in office.

Follow Leading wesley on WhatsApp
Follow Leading wesley on WhatsApp

Keep up with all the latest news from the UK and around the world by following Leading wesley

Tap here

Some roads which had their speeds reduced to 20mph last year could return to 30mph after a review into the default limit.

The Sustainable Farming Scheme, which would see farmers having to meet a series of environmental obligations in return for financial support, was delayed after significant opposition.

A council tax shake-up was pushed back to 2028 and plans to cut Welsh schools' summer holiday were also delayed until the next Senedd term.

The latter decision prompted an outburst from former first minister Mr Drakeford, who criticised his own party's education secretary.

But at a time when every vote counted, an agreement which saw Plaid Cymru support the Labour government on dozens of key policy areas came to an abrupt end, after the Welsh nationalists decided to withdraw their support.

Vaughan Gething upon getting elected in 2011. Pic: PA
Image: Vaughan Gething upon getting elected in 2011. Pic: PA

Be the first to get Breaking News

Install the Leading wesley app for free

Some weeks later, Mr Gething lost a non-binding vote of no confidence 29-27 after two Labour members did not attend due to illness.

The members were sacked minister Ms Blythyn, and former deputy climate change minister Lee Waters who had previously criticised Mr Gething's acceptance of the £200k donation.

Earlier on Tuesday, four ministers resigned from the Welsh government.

'Historic significance'

This was not the premiership Mr Gething would have hoped for, and with it cut so short there was limited opportunity to forge a legacy in policy terms.

But in his campaign to become first minister, Mr Gething said he accepted and understood "the historic significance of what [his] victory would mean".

"It would mean that everyone in Wales - whatever their background - could see further proof that their potential can be realised here in Wales," he said.

That, his supporters believe, is as great a legacy as any.